David Jones heads for Davy Jones's Locker

By John Ogilvie

News has just broken that David Jones, the 188-year-old department store, has entered voluntary administration after negotiations with Westfield broke down.

My immediate sympathies go out to David Jones's almost 6000 employees. The people on the shop floor and in the back offices didn't design the business model, and are not responsible for the company going under. I hope that they are all able to land on their feet.

Even before the physical stores have closed down, the blame game has begun. Many are pointing the finger at the Albanese government, and some are even saying that the government should have stepped in to prevent this from happening, either by bailing out the company or by raising tariffs on imported goods.

Let's unpack this situation. Why David Jones has gone under, if the federal government is really to blame, and if the people arguing for protectionism could end up with a serious case of buyer's remorse.

The Gradual Decline

As stated at the beginning of this piece, the immediate trigger for David Jones entering voluntary administration was due to the company being unable to pay its rent to Westfield after 30 September.

At first, one may be tempted to blame this on the recent rises in interest rates, but the ownership history of the company since the mid-2010s tells a different story.

In 2014, Woolworths Holdings bought David Jones for $2.1 billion. After several years of underperformance, they sold the business to Anchorage Capital Partners in late 2022 for around $100 million. This was a clear sign that the company was in trouble.

The problem isn't just with the way that David Jones has been run as a business. There is a deeper structural issue here. The traditional department store is completely antiquated in the world of online shopping and specialist chains. It's a business model that has been losing relevance for decades.

Department stores in general have seen their share of Australian retail spending decline over the decades. Anchorage Capital itself reported a $74 million loss in 2024 alone. Department stores in other countries have faced the same structural squeeze.

The brutal truth is that what's more surprising than David Jones entering administration is the fact that it managed to survive for as long as it did.

Blaming the Government?

I haven't exactly been shy about my criticism of various Albanese government policy initiatives in recent history. So it may come as a surprise to some that I don't put any significant blame for David Jones going under at the feet of Jim Chalmers or anyone else in the federal cabinet.

While the timing may be convenient for those looking to blame the incumbent government, the evidence simply doesn't support this conclusion. The broader structural and strategic problems were well established long before Albanese first became prime minister. Woolworth's sale of the business at a 95% discount in 2022 already demonstrated that it was in trouble. The current cost-of-living crisis certainly hasn't helped, but at the very most, it's only accelerated a process that was already happening.

Aside from blaming the current government, some have argued that the government should have intervened to keep David Jones afloat, either by bailing them out directly, or through other measures that override ordinary market outcomes (like a forced lease renegotiation, or raising tariffs to make imported goods less competitive).

Any government action to save David Jones would have come at a cost to the taxpayer and everyday consumers, rather than on the parties who made the bad business decisions that led to this outcome in the first place. Tariffs would raise prices for everyday consumers while doing absolutely nothing to fix high occupancy costs, or the general shift to online stores and specialist retailers.

Propping up an outdated business model only serves to distort capital and labor markets. It delays the reallocation of those resources into more productive sectors, and the result is that everyday people pay higher prices and have fewer choices.

If the government were to intervene to prevent David Jones from going under, it would set a precedent that would be hard to limit. What happens in the future when other struggling companies or sectors come asking for a handout? The result is an environment where the government increasingly picks winners and losers, which results in higher costs and less pressure on firms to adapt.

The hardship for current employees is real, and I feel for them. But shielding an outdated retail format from the consequences of its own long decline does not protect those workers in the long run. It shifts the cost onto taxpayers and consumers while delaying the reallocation of capital into businesses that can actually compete. The result is higher prices, fewer choices, and an open invitation for the next struggling firm to ask for the same special treatment.

The better outcome, for everyone, is that those resources move to businesses that do not need political protection to survive.